Skip to main content
Who is this for? Users with the Organisation Administrator and Recruiter roles.
Evaluation criteria are the foundation of how Hello Recruiter’s AI assesses candidates. Each criterion is one thing you want to know about a candidate, such as “WMS proficiency” or “Onsite availability”. Well-defined criteria lead to more accurate, fair, and consistent evaluations.

Setting Up Evaluation Criteria

Where to Set Criteria

  • When you create a job — step 3, Evaluation Criteria, shows criteria the AI suggests from your job description.
  • On an existing job — open the job and choose Interview Evaluation from the Job Navigation menu on the left. The page is titled How Should Hello Recruiter Evaluate Candidates?
Interview Evaluation with numbered labels: 1 AI Suggested, 2 importance and weight, 3 edit weight, 4 Guidance for Hello AI, 5 Remove

A job's Interview Evaluation page, with one criterion expanded

Importance and Weight

Every criterion has an importance level and a numeric weight:
  • Click Required, Recommended, or Good-to-have to change a criterion’s importance.
  • Click the pencil next to the weight to fine-tune it (for example, 90 instead of 100 for a slightly less critical must-have).
  • Criteria with higher weights have a bigger effect on the candidate’s overall score. Weights don’t need to add up to any total.

Guidance for Hello AI

Expand a criterion (click the arrow on the right) to see its Guidance for Hello AI. The AI treats this text as a strict instruction when scoring that criterion, so write it as a clear rule, for example:
Mark yes if the candidate has personally run daily floor operations (receiving to shipping) and owned throughput or accuracy targets. Oversight-only roles count as no.
Criteria the AI created are tagged AI Suggested. Review their guidance like you would your own.

Adding and Removing Criteria

  • Click Add Evaluation Criterion at the bottom of the list to add your own.
  • Expand a criterion and click Remove to delete it.

Save Your Changes

As soon as you change a criterion, a You have unsaved changes banner appears at the top. Click Save to apply your changes, or Revert to go back to the previous version. Refreshing the page before you save loses your changes.
You have unsaved changes banner with Save and Revert buttons and the note that updates only affect future applicants

Save or revert your changes

Updates only affect future applicants. Candidates who were already evaluated keep their existing scores.

Writing Good Criteria

Make each criterion measurable. Instead of “Good communicator”, write “Can explain complex technical concepts clearly to non-technical stakeholders.”
Keep Required for true must-haves. If everything is Required, nothing stands out. Move learnable skills to Recommended or Good-to-have.
Cover practical requirements too. Criteria like location fit or availability (“Onsite Miami fit”, “Immediate availability”) help the AI flag mismatches early.

Creating a Job

Candidate Scorecard

Improving Results